sallymurphy.com.au

Sally Murphy, Australian author

Poetry Friday: This is Just to Say

by 46 Comments

Earlier this week, I posted about mentor text, and how can use them to inspire new poems of your own. Today, I wanted to share another effort. This one is based on what I suspect might be the most-used mentor-text poem ever, and a poem which changed my world.

First, the poem, by William Carlos Williams, which I hope you’ve come across before:

This is Just to Say

I have eaten
the plums
that were in
the icebox    (read the rest of this copyright poem here)
This poem, written as a note of apology, was one of the first free verse poems I remember reading. It was my first year of high school, and our teacher gave us the poem to read, discuss and, yes, mimic in poems of our own. I remember being amazed that poems could be written that way. Years later, when I wrote my first verse novel, Pearl Verses the World, I gave that experience to Pearl:
Pearl Verses the World
One day Granny read me
A poem
About a man stealing a plum
Granny, I remember saying
Why are there no rhymes
In that poem?
Granny laughed.
Why, Pearl, didn’t you know
A poem does not have to rhyme?…
A poem, comes
When it is needed
And writes itself
In the way it needs
To get its point across.
(from Pearl Verses the World,  2009, p. 63 Copyright Sally Murphy)

 

Anyway, back to the use of a mentor text. Williams’ This is Just to Say ahs been used in classrooms and by writers as a mentor text many many times.  There have even been books written based on the poem, my favourite of which is Joyce Sidman’s This is Just to Say: Poems of  Apology and Forgiveness.

Here is my own attempt a ‘This is Just to Say’ poem. I stuck with  the food  theme, and also gave an extra nod to Williams’ poem with my mention of plums.

This is just to say

I have eaten

the cake

that was in

the pantry

 

and which

you were probably

saving

for visitors.

 

Forgive me.

We had

no peaches

and no icy plums.

 

(Copyright Sally Murphy, 2015)

 

Have you ever written a This is Just to Say Poem? Or do you have your own favourite mentor text? I’d love to hear about it.

This post is part of Poetry Friday, where bloggers around the world post about poetry every Friday. Later today, you’ll see a round up of all the Poetry Friday posts at Penny’s blog.

Comments

  1. This is just to say

    I am late
    to the party
    of poems
    with no rhymes

    I was twirling
    around other
    posts.
    I should
    have come here first.
    Now I know.

    Forgive me
    for leaving
    so early
    and forgetting
    to say
    goodbye.

    Margaret Simon with a nod to Catherine Flynn for sending me here through Laura Shovan’s Facebook poetry challenge.

    Reply

  2. Don’t you love it when the comments get as (or more!) interesting than your post? This is not to say that your post was uninteresting or anything less than juicy…

    🙂

    Reply

  4. Oh, my goodness….the comment string is as fun as the post! Wonderful post, Sally. I remember when I first discovered novels in verse and I felt like the only one in the world that had figured out just how wonderful they were (yah. no publisher, author. Just me wrapped up in a cloud of wow). My first and continued response is….I want do DO THAT!

    This is Just to Say

    I have read
    the book
    you left
    by your chair.

    and which
    you were probably
    going to read
    after supper.

    Forgive me
    it was suspenseful
    a real page turner
    til the dog died.

    Reply

    • Love it, Linda. I felt the same way when I discovered verse novels.
      I love the twist at the end of yours – though of course it’s sad.

      Reply

  5. Sally, I love your poem! And my fourth grade son, who is joining me on this Poetry Friday, says, “Great job!” as well. My favorite mentor text at this time is Mary Oliver’s “New and Selected Poems.” I agree that mentor texts can help inspire and grow us as writers.

    Reply

  7. This is Just to Say

    I have eaten
    the minutes
    that were in
    the present

    and which
    you were probably
    saving
    for today.

    They slipped
    through my fingers
    so sweaty
    and so hot.

    Thanks for the prompt to play, Sally. x

    Reply

  16. My 2nd-grade granddaughter’s class just wrote to this poem earlier in the year, Sally. She was very excited about it. I like that you gave your own nod to the plums. William Carlos Williams would be grateful.

    Reply

  17. This is just to say
    I have beaten
    a poem
    to death

    I tried to
    rhyme it
    and sweeten it
    for readers

    Forgive me
    I should have
    let it
    breathe.

    Thanks for the mentor text today!

    Reply

  18. This is just to say
    I ate the comment
    that was here.
    It was well-rounded,
    thoughtful,
    insightful.
    Forgive me.
    But it was so sweet,
    straight from the dicy box.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *