In my dayjob as a lecturer in literacy and education, the two key messages I constantly try to impart to these future teachers is that if you are going to teach reading, you need to be a reader yourself and if you are going to teach writing, you need to be a writer. Sometimes I think my students get sick of me repeating these messages, but I also try to model what that looks like in every class, by reading to and with my students, and writing with them too.
The unit I am teaching this Semester is an elective called Creative Literacies, and it is all about teaching literacy, and the subject English, in creative ways and to develop creativity in students. Each week we look at different aspects of the curriculum – reading, writing, nonfiction, visual arts and more. But this week’s topic is my favourite one: Poetry.
I love teaching this class – although one two hour block seems to go past sooooo quickly. It’s less of a lecture and more of impassioned call to action, beginning with an explanation to my students of my own love of poetry and how that love was almost quashed by high school English and the dreaded exercises in Practical Criticism (or Prac. Crit. as they were always called).
If you are not familiar with a prac. crit, don’t worry. What this involved was being given an unseen poem, and then having to write an essay about it. That was pretty much the guidance I remember receiving. And I had no idea how to do it. I was, apparently, required to read the poem, see past the words to all the hidden layers and then write eloquently about what it meant and how the poem imparted that meaning.
I remember feeling dumb.
Every
single
time.
It seemed my classmates could see those layers. But I just felt dread. Was I getting the ‘right’ meaning? And was this meaning imparted through iambic pentameter? Trochaic something-or-other?
Amazingly, I managed to pass English Literature in my final year 12 exams, but it was my worst subject. Luckily I also took regular English, and that was my best. And somehow, in spite of that experience, I still loved poetry – just not in the classroom. And ended up studying literature at university and, eventually, completed a PhdD focussing on children’s poetry – though there was not a prac. crit. in sight. [Side note: On my very first teaching practice as a student teacher, an English teacher called Ron taught his students how to write a prac. crit. It was the first time I had heard it explained in a way I understood. And I have never forgotten that lesson – and I used his method to teach my own students for many years In fact, if I do say so myself, I could write a pretty mean prac. crit these days, if I wanted to. Which I don’t.]
Anyway, back to this week’s class. As well as telling my own poetry journey as an introduction, we spent our class looking at brilliant examples of poetry, including verse novels, some simple writing exercises and lots of talk about poetry. By the end of the class I could see that my students were enthused about poetry – partly because of the class, and partly because they are bright individuals who already have deep interests in reading and writing which will make them fine teachers.
If you are reading this and are a teacher, or future teacher, this is the takeaway I want to offer:
- Don’t be scared of poetry. If the layers are too obscure, it’s the wrong poem.
- There is no right answer for any poem – and, in writing, no right answer in form either.
- Use more poetry in your classroom! It doesn’t have to be siloed into a two week unit at the end of term 2. It can be a daily offering – present in your class library, adorning the walls of your room, written and read alongside any other form. And if you are stuck for ideas, hit me up!
I’m going to finish with a poem (of course), not freshly written, but which seems apt to share today.
Now I’m off to enjoy more poetry because it’s Poetry Friday! The round up is over at Jone’s blog. There is always plenty of poetry goodness on offer – and no one expects a prac. crit. to be written afterwards 🙂
Susan Thomsen says
That’s a fun poem, Sally, and some good advice. Studying poetry in high school was awful! We spent so much time dissecting meter and looking for symbols that I completely avoided it in college. Thank goodness a writing class I took later was wonderful! It included reading & writing poetry.
Carol Varsalona says
Sally, we are communicators of the same message to teachers. I have been a consultant to teachers and school districts since I retired. My work like yours is passion-filled with creative ideas for teachers to help students find their creativity and become lifelong readers and writers. Someday we should talk about our similar ideas. Your poem is just perfect for Poem in a Pocket Day,.
Sally says
Thank you Carol – and yes, someday we will talk about many things, I hope.
PATRICIA J FRANZ says
Love your teaching enthusiasm! My nieces are teachers of 7th and 8th grade English and –YAY!– they are working poetry in across the year!
Sally says
Hooray for your clever nieces! Thanks for dropping by.
Linda Baie says
I had the pleasure of open-ended work within my school teaching & shared poems often, gave choices to what students might wish to do, hoping they would learn to love poetry before high school might befuddle them, as you wrote, Sally. Thanks for sharing what you do. I bet your students will remember & pass it on!
Sally says
Thank you Linda.
Bridget Magee says
Would love to take a class from you, Sally, most especially one about poetry! YOU’RE the ‘right answer’. 🙂
Sally says
Gosh thank you Bridget! I think you would teach me just as much as I could teach you!
Linda Mitchell says
I can feel the passion in your words. I just want to scream, “Amen!” I really don’t believe that anyone doesn’t enjoy poetry. It’s what they must do with poetry that they don’t enjoy. This week, I set up review “stations” in the library for our upcoming end-of-year tests. One station was a poetry station. I hung out there and played with the poems with students. They too want to know the “right” answer and that is just soul crushing. I hope we in education can push for learning that makes better connections. Thanks for being someone who does.
Sally says
Amen indeed. That soul-crushingness of right answers, and testing, and standardisation can be heavy indeed. But luckily we have educators and poetry lovers like you to keep making differences, one star at a time.